The Repair Was Done Badly. Now What?
If your insurer arranged the repair, your insurer is answerable for it. That single fact is the one most people do not know, and it is the one that settles most of these complaints.
- Hackbridge SM6 7HN
- Any insurer · your choice of repairer
Who is actually responsible
This is the part that decides everything else, and it turns on who chose the garage.
| Who arranged the repair | Who answers for it |
|---|---|
| Your insurer’s approved repairer | Your insurer |
| A garage your insurer told you to use | Your insurer |
| Your own choice, with the insurer saying clearly it would not be responsible | The garage |
| Your own choice, with no such warning given | Possibly still your insurer |
| Your own choice, but the insurer took control of the repair | Possibly still your insurer |
That is the Financial Ombudsman Service’s stated approach. The practical upshot: if the work came through your insurer, complain to your insurer. Do not let them point you at the bodyshop and step back.
What the repair is supposed to achieve
The test is not whether the repair looks acceptable. It is whether the car has been put back to the condition it was in before the damage.
If it has not, the Ombudsman may require the insurer to have it put right by their repairer, to pay for you to use a repairer of your own, or — where the car cannot be properly restored — to write it off and pay you its pre-accident market value.
The evidence that actually wins
These complaints turn on evidence, and one kind beats all the others.
- An independent engineer’s report. The Ombudsman describes independent expert evidence as what it often finds most persuasive. Yours will cost you, and it is frequently the thing that decides it.
- Contemporaneous evidence beats later evidence. In one upheld decision the insurer’s paint specialist report was written after the event to record findings nobody had documented at the time, and little weight was given to it.
- Photographs of the car before the damage. The condition it was in beforehand is half the test, and almost nobody has this. Old MOT photographs, sale adverts and service records all help.
- A written opinion from another bodyshop. Cheaper than an engineer and still useful. Ask for the cause, not just the fault.
- Dates. When the car went in, when it came back, when you first complained. Timelines decide arguments about whether a fault was present on return.
The "you should have spotted it sooner" argument
Insurers sometimes argue a paint fault would have been visible within days of collection, so a complaint months later must be about something new.
It is not automatically wrong — fresh stone chips and kerbing genuinely do cause bubbling, and one Ombudsman decision went against the customer for exactly that reason. But it depends on the timeline, and in another the argument failed because the final inspection had happened only six days after the car was painted and other paint on the same car needed redoing within two months.
If that argument is put to you, ask for the dates it relies on and check them against your own.
How to escalate
- Complain to the insurer in writing. Not the bodyshop, if the insurer arranged it. Set out the fault, the dates and what you want done.
- Ask for their final response. That is the formal document that opens the next door.
- Get your own evidence while you wait. An inspection, photographs in daylight, a second opinion.
- Take it to the Ombudsman. Free, and they routinely handle repair-quality complaints. Normally within six months of the final response.
- Keep driving it or not? If it is unsafe, stop. If it is cosmetic, carry on and photograph it as it changes.
This is general information about how motor claims usually work, not legal or financial advice. Your own policy wording decides what you are entitled to, so read it, or ring us on About Us · FAQ
020 4629 9469 and we will talk it through against the damage in front of us.
What we can do
We inspect repairs other people have done and tell you what we find, in writing, with photographs. Not a sales exercise — sometimes the answer is that the work is acceptable and the colour difference is one you will stop seeing.
Where it is not acceptable, a written report naming the fault and its cause is exactly the evidence that moves a complaint. We are on no insurer’s panel, so we have no relationship with whoever did the work to protect.
Whoever you claim through, the repairer is your choice. KITH is on no insurer’s panel, which means no labour time has been pre-agreed on your car’s behalf — we estimate the job as it needs doing and argue it with the engineer if we have to.
Before you act on any of this
This is general information about how motor claims usually work, not legal or financial advice. Your own policy wording decides what you are entitled to, so read it, or ring us on 020 4629 9469 and we will talk it through against the damage in front of us.
Price your repair now
Put your registration in and we will price it. Prefer to talk? Call 020 4629 9469 or WhatsApp us.
Your questions answered
The bodyshop says it is within tolerance.
Ask to see it with them, outside, in daylight. "Within tolerance" is reasonable for a measured difference and not for something you can see from across the road. If the insurer arranged the repair, put the complaint to the insurer regardless of what the bodyshop says.
Can I just take it somewhere else and send the bill?
Not safely. Tell the insurer the repair has failed and give them the chance to put it right first. The Ombudsman can require them to pay for another repairer, but that normally follows a complaint rather than a bill arriving unannounced.
How long do I have to complain?
Raise it with the insurer as soon as you notice. For the Ombudsman, it is normally six months from the insurer’s final response, and generally six years from the event. Sooner is always stronger, because paint faults are easier to attribute early.
Does it cost anything to go to the Ombudsman?
Not to you. It is free for consumers. You may choose to pay for an engineer’s report, and that is usually the money worth spending.
What if the car cannot be properly repaired at all?
Then the Ombudsman may require the insurer to write it off and pay the pre-accident market value. That is the remedy where a car cannot be restored to its previous condition.
