Why Some Repairs Don't Match

A repair that does not match almost always failed at one of six points, and five of them are preventable. Knowing which one went wrong tells you whether it can be put right.

  • Hackbridge SM6 7HN
  • Any insurer · your choice of repairer
Loading instant quote…

The six reasons

What went wrongHow it looksFixable?
No blendingA visible step in shade at the shut lineYes — redo with a blend
Code used without variant checkClose but consistently off across the panelYes — rematch and respray
No spray-out cardWrong from the moment it driedYes
Matched under workshop lightRight indoors, wrong in daylightYes
Flake laid down differentlyShifts shade as you walk past itYes, with technique
Panel was already a different shadeThe repair matches the code, not the carYes — match the car

How to tell which one happened

  1. Look at it in daylight, outside. Not in a garage, not under a streetlight. If it only shows outdoors, it was matched under the wrong light.
  2. Walk past it at an angle. If the shade shifts as you move, it is a metallic flake problem rather than a colour problem.
  3. Find the edge. If there is a clean line at the shut and the panel is uniformly different, it was not blended. If the difference fades out, it was blended and the mix was off.
  4. Compare with the panel two along. If the repaired panel matches its neighbour but both differ from the rest of the car, the original panel had already been painted before.

What to do about it

If we did the work, tell us. The paint guarantee covers a year and a match we are not happy with is not a match we expect you to live with. Bring it back and we will look at it in daylight with you.

If someone else did it, the position depends who paid. On an insurance repair through the insurer’s own network, the insurer guarantees the work and the complaint goes to them. On a repair you paid for directly, it is between you and that bodyshop, and a clear photograph in daylight is worth more than any description.

Whoever you claim through, the repairer is your choice. KITH is on no insurer’s panel, which means no labour time has been pre-agreed on your car’s behalf — we estimate the job as it needs doing and argue it with the engineer if we have to.

The one that is genuinely hard

There is an honest exception in the list above. A car with badly faded original paint — a red that has gone pink on the roof, a dark blue that has chalked — can be matched to the car as it is now, and the match will be good. What it cannot do is stay good, because the repaired panel has fresh pigment and the rest of the car does not. It will diverge again over the next few years.

We say that up front on a car in that condition, because the alternative is you discovering it in two summers and thinking we got it wrong.

Price your repair now

Put your registration in and we will price it. Prefer to talk? Call 020 4629 9469 or WhatsApp us.

Your questions answered

Can a bad match be corrected without a full respray?

Usually, yes. Most of the six causes are fixed by redoing the panel properly with a blend, rather than painting the whole car.

How long do I have to complain?

With us, the paint guarantee is a year, and sooner is better for a colour issue because it is easiest to assess before the new paint has weathered at all.

The bodyshop says it is within tolerance.

Ask to see it with them, outside, in daylight. "Within tolerance" is a reasonable phrase for a measured difference and an unreasonable one for something you can see from across the road.

Does a mismatched repair affect the car’s value?

It can, because a visible repair invites questions about what else was done. It is worth putting right before selling.

Chat on WhatsApp