The Other Driver's Insurer Called Me Directly

It is called third party capture, it is legal, and it is not done for your benefit. They are trying to control the cost of a claim they expect to pay, and the cheapest way to do that is to handle it before you involve anyone else.

  • Hackbridge SM6 7HN
  • Any insurer · your choice of repairer
Loading instant quote…

What is actually happening

The at-fault driver has reported the accident to their own insurer. That insurer can see they are likely to pay, and they know the bill is lower if they handle it directly than if you go through your own insurer and a credit hire company.

So they ring you, often within a day, sound helpful, and offer to sort the repair and a car. All of which may be perfectly fine. It is simply worth knowing whose interests the call serves.

What you keep either way

  • Your choice of repairer. Accepting their help does not oblige you to use their bodyshop.
  • A like-for-like replacement vehicle. Not whatever is cheapest on their list.
  • Your out-of-pocket costs. Recovery, storage, loss of earnings.
  • The right to involve your own insurer instead. At any point.

What to say on the call

  1. Take their details rather than giving yours. Company, claim reference, name, direct number. Then say you will come back to them.
  2. Do not discuss how the accident happened. Not in detail, and not on a recorded line, before liability is settled.
  3. Do not accept any offer on the first call. Particularly not a cash settlement figure, which is usually below the real repair cost.
  4. Tell your own insurer it happened. Even if you end up going direct. They need to know.
  5. Get a real repair figure first. Then you can judge whether what they are offering covers it.

The cash offer

A common move is an offer to settle in cash rather than repair the car. It can be genuinely convenient, particularly on an older car you are happy to live with as it is.

The catch is that the figure is usually built from their assessment rather than a real quote, and once you accept it the claim is closed. If the damage turns out to be worse than it looked — which is what strip-down is for — that is now your problem.

Get the car estimated properly before accepting any cash figure. If the offer covers it, take it with confidence. If it does not, you now have a document that says so.

Before you act on any of this

This is general information about how motor claims usually work, not legal or financial advice. Your own policy wording decides what you are entitled to, so read it, or ring us on About Us · FAQ
020 4629 9469 and we will talk it through against the damage in front of us.

Price your repair now

Put your registration in and we will price it. Prefer to talk? Call 020 4629 9469 or WhatsApp us.

Your questions answered

Do I have to speak to them at all?

No. You can decline and tell them to deal with your insurer. That is often the simplest answer if you find the call uncomfortable.

They said using my own insurer will cost me my excess. True?

Usually true in the short term, and recoverable once liability settles. It is a fair point rather than a trick — but it is being made because it suits them.

Is it a scam?

No, it is a recognised and lawful practice. The thing to be alert to is pressure to decide quickly, and any suggestion you do not have a choice of repairer.

Can I use you if I go through them?

Yes. The choice of repairer is yours whoever is paying, and we deal with any insurer.

Chat on WhatsApp