Compulsory vs Voluntary Excess

Your excess is two numbers added together, and people routinely forget the second one until they claim. The one you chose to save money is usually the bigger of the two.

  • Hackbridge SM6 7HN
  • Any insurer · your choice of repairer
Loading instant quote…

The two halves

CompulsoryVoluntary
Who sets itThe insurerYou
WhyYour car, age, licence and claims historyTo bring the premium down
Can you change itNoAt renewal
Payable on a claimYesYes

Both are payable, and they stack. A £250 compulsory with a £500 voluntary means £750 out of your pocket before the insurer contributes anything.

The trap with a high voluntary excess

Raising your voluntary excess lowers your premium, which feels like free money at renewal. It is a bet: you are wagering that you will not claim, and the stake is the difference.

The arithmetic that catches people is that most bodywork claims are small. A bumper, a door, a wing — these are frequently in the hundreds rather than the thousands. Set a voluntary excess of £500 and you have effectively uninsured yourself against the most common damage there is, while still paying for cover against the rare expensive sort.

Picking a sensible figure

  • Work out what you could pay tomorrow without it being a problem. That is your ceiling.
  • Compare the premium saving against the extra excess. Saving £40 a year to add £250 of excess takes six years to break even, and only if you never claim.
  • Remember the compulsory figure sits underneath it. Ask what it is before you choose the voluntary one — it is often not on the summary page.
  • If you drive somewhere your car gets knocked regularly, a low excess earns its keep.

Where it actually matters

It is not the big crash that tests your excess choice, because at that point you are claiming regardless. It is the £400 bumper. With a £150 total excess you claim without thinking; with a £750 total excess you pay for it yourself, and the question becomes whether the premium you saved covered it.

That is also the honest case for getting a direct price before you call your insurer at all. We will tell you the figure, and then the comparison is a real one rather than a guess.

Before you act on any of this

This is general information about how motor claims usually work, not legal or financial advice. Your own policy wording decides what you are entitled to, so read it, or ring us on About Us · FAQ
020 4629 9469 and we will talk it through against the damage in front of us.

Price your repair now

Put your registration in and we will price it. Prefer to talk? Call 020 4629 9469 or WhatsApp us.

Your questions answered

Does the voluntary excess apply to every claim?

Usually yes on accidental damage. Windscreen claims almost always carry a separate and lower glass excess instead, so check that section specifically.

Can I lower my voluntary excess mid-policy?

Not normally — it is set for the policy term. You change it at renewal.

Is a £0 voluntary excess ever worth it?

Occasionally, on a cheap-to-insure car where the premium barely moves. Mostly the premium difference is small enough that the middle ground is better value.

Do I pay both halves even on a non-fault claim?

Yes, and then you recover the lot once liability settles — if you chase it.

Chat on WhatsApp